Dual Anesthetics Preferred in the United States

Anesthesia is commonly used by dentists when they want to ensure young patients re­main calm during an operation and feel as little pain as possible afterward. Dentist anesthesiologists may use either general or local anesthesia, but some choose to use both with children, de­spite conflicting research on the combined approach. The journal Anes­thesia Pro­gress reports on a survey given to members of the Amer­ican Society of Dentist Anesthes­iologists (ASDA), asking about anesthesia choices for young patients and reasons for supplementing general anesthesia with local anesthesia.

Prior studies have found that local anesthesia can benefit children undergoing dental procedures. Ad­vantages include less distress in recovering from anesthesia and less pain after extractions. How­ever, other reports have found no difference in postoperative pain. Some dentists skip local anesthesia in most cases be­cause they fear the additional anesthetic will cause children to bite their lip or cheek after surgery. The current survey found that 90% of responding dentist anesthesiologists prefer the combined ap­proach when treating some or most of their young patients. These respondents said the pairing makes it easier to stabilize the children’s vital signs while decreasing the depth of general anesthesia. They also re­ported that the children ex­perience less pain and recover more quickly with dual anesthetics. Half of them decide on the ap­proach based on the patient, and 40% supplement general with local anesthesia in all but a few cases. The survey also showed strong links between the type of practice, type of procedure, and whether there are other dentists involved. Most re­sponding ASDA members ad­minister only the anesthesia for children in dental offices and let the operating dentist decide whether to use local anesthesia. About 27% of respondents said they make the decision because they both administer the anesthesia and perform the operation. Local anesthesia is most often added when dentists were preparing to extract permanent or primary teeth.

Despite the preference for administering both types of anesthesia, the survey authors found that little scientific evidence is available to ASDA members in making their decision. The authors noted that no prospective double-blind studies conclusively argue for or against the combined usage.


(Source: Anesthesia Progress, 2014, Volume 61, Number 1)